#Unison midi chord pack free reddit full
#Unison midi chord pack free reddit license

They can wait 90 days – an eternity in Internet time. They can contact whomever made the complaint and get them to reverse it – which doesn’t work here, if Unison’s whole goal was removing the video. The problem is, creators have little recourse once that strike is processed. You can read up on this world of hurt on Google’s own site:Īfter all the recent fears about the EU and filtering, automated filtering doesn’t result in a strike – strikes require an explicit request. In this case, Unison can simply use a made-up copyright claim as a tool to kill a video they didn’t like. It’s easy to file a copyright claim, but hard to get videos reinstated once that claim is filed.Īs a result: there’s almost nothing stopping someone from filing a fraudulent copyright claim just because they don’t like your video. Here’s where YouTube’s scale and automation, though, collide with the intricacies of copyright law requirements (mainly in the USA, but possibly soon impacted by changes in the European Union).

#Unison midi chord pack free reddit license

While I’m not a lawyer, this should fall dead center under the doctrine of fair use as well as the royalty free license provided by the developers themselves.

The copyright claim appears to be based on the the pack included for demonstration purposes in his video. What makes this story so disturbing: not only is YouTube’s lax structure vulnerable to abuse, it seems to actively encourage scammers. I’m not knocking their hustle by NO MEANS, but offer a product that is 100% YOURS!!!!! Do I like doing videos like these? No, but it’s necessary when people are using their influence for the wrong things. It’s censorship at it finest! YouTube as a company has lost all of it’s charm when it stop caring about the community on here. It’s sad that YouTube allows shills and dishonest companies to strike honest reviewers.

I don’t care if that happens because I’m not going to stand for people hustling you. I’ve reached out to Unison for further comment.Ī video about Unison Audio copyright striking my “Unison Audio Chord MIDI Pack Scam” video! This is a channel strike which is affects my monetization rights and could get my channel deleted. At this point, our story is picked up by Tim Webb at the excellent Discchord blog, who choose a nice, succinct headline: Calling the product a “scam,” he says he pointed to other, free sources for the same MIDI content – meaning that, as it wasn’t actually original, at best the Unison product amounts to plagiarism.Īs if it weren’t already strange enough that these developers were selling MIDI files of chords, they then responded to Ave Mcree’s video by filing a copyright claim. Maybe I’m missing something, but I definitely can’t figure out this product from their documentation.Īve Mcree aka Traptendo, a well-known YouTube host, decided to take on the developers. It’d be a little bit like someone selling you a Build Your Own House Construction Set that was made up of a bag of nails… and the nails were just ones they’d found lying on the ground. They claim that this will help you to create chords “with the right notes, in the right order” without theory background – except most of the drag-and-drop material is made up of root position triads, labeled via terminology you’d need some theory to even read. You can watch the demo video on their product page – at first, I couldn’t quite believe my eyes. They even demo the product in Ableton Live, which already contains built-in chord and arpeggiator tools. Not real presets, but just raw MIDI chords.

#Unison midi chord pack free reddit full

But the actual product appears to be just a set of folders full of MIDI files … of, like, chords. Understandably, users without musical training may like the idea of drag-and-drop chords and harmony – nothing wrong with that.

This US$67 pack is already, on its surface, a bit strange. The story begins with around a product, the Unison MIDI Chord Pack. But the platform’s esoteric rules are also ripe for abuse – as one YouTube host claims. YouTube is elevating new voices to prominence in music technology as in other fields.